Thursday, June 23, 2005

Andrew Murray - tennis wonderkind...

Listening to the radio, I have noticed how many times a drooling FiveLive commentary team are most careful to emphasise that Andrew Murray is from SCOTLAND - and not Britain..... "Murray from Scotland"... "Plucky Scot, Murray"..... etc, etc....

It's funny, but I can't remember Tim Henman - when he was regularly getting to the quarters and semis of Wimbledon - EVER being called 'The Englishman, Tim Henman' or 'England's Tim Henman' or 'England's great tennis hope, Tim Henman'...

He has always been known as 'Britain's Tim Henman'...... Hasn't he?

I'm all for national pride - so why, when an Englishman is successful, he is 'British' - and when a Scot is successful, he is 'Scottish'? And if the media start to call him/her 'British' - they are accused of 'hijacking' their own Scottish heroes...

You can see this happening all over sport today - for example, in F1motor racing. David Coulthard has a Scottish Saltire plastered all over his helmet - Jensen Button has a Union flag on his. When he changed it to a St George's cross last summer to support the England football team, he was assailed by an ITV commentator, demanding to know why he was being so 'un-British' and unpatriotic by removing the Union Flag - and replacing it with a "Red and White squiggle"..... The design was artistic, in the same way that the Union flag was, but Button still felt the need to explain and to justify it... Needless to say, he made Button feel embarrassed and uncomfortable - and sure enough, at the next race Jensen had replaced the St George's cross with the British emblem....
David's identity is strongly Scottish and that is perfectly fine.. when he is mentioned, he is 'The Scot, David Coulthard'... Button, however is always referred to as 'The British driver, Jensen Button'....

It is clear that as far as the establishment are concerned, Scottish sportsmen/women are Scottish, Welsh sportsmen/women are Welsh and Northern Irish sportsmen/women are Northern Irish.......
But what of English sportsmen/women? Well, of course, they're all from BRITAIN, obviously!!!!

18 comments:

simon said...

When I try to explain to people over here that my country doesn't exist anymore, they have a really hard time believing it.

Their next reaction is always, why did we allow this to happen?

Well, bugadifino. But I guess it's always the minorities in any larger society who hold on to their culture and identity. Maybe it's an argument for Europe...the more we feel subsumed by a larger organisation, the greater the interest will be in reviving our English identity.

Scrapping the Royals might be a good place to start. I wouldn't lose any sleep if we were to break up the Union either. Four parliaments, none of which would have any jurisdiction over anything outside their own territories. Scotland would probably empty overnight.

John said...

I'm no cricket fan but I have always been puzzled by the M.C.C.

Mike said...

Scrapping the Royals might be a good place to start.

Scrapping the entire toadying British Government would be a better place to start. Starting with Tory 'Mr U Turn' Blair as the first against the wall, on second thoughts start with his utterly awful wife Cherie Blair.

Birdman said...

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/newspaper/0,,175-1668367,00.html

Jim said...

Oddly I have exactly the same perception. Only from the opposite perspective. I tend to hear television and radio sports commentators talk about successful English Sportsmen and women as English, but Scots as British! Maybe it has something to do with the success thing, which you can't really associate Tim Henman with (grins)

Timesnewroman

phdmonkey said...

Oooh, controversial. But as a big hairy Scotsman I agree with the above post - often it seems that when an English team/person do well, they are English, and when they do badly they are British. Likewise when a Scottish team/person do well they are British, and when they go back to normaility (i.e. doing crap) they are Scottish. I think the BBC and ITV are to blame - let's lobby them so that English are English and Scottish are Scottish and British teams (athletics etc) are British.

Andy Creevy said...

Hey there As usual you hit the nail on the head Could be hughely talented is hugely out wonder if 007 went up and eliminated the dodgy Spanish Umpire who Kept Malbandian in it during the fourth. Oh by the way Steve. Help me still can't get into my own blog am considering starting a new one

hannah said...

I have heard it both ways-english being english and british and then scottish being scots and british and the same with the welsh and irish.

Living in america i have experienced the same thing. Everyone here always introduces me to their friends as being british when i am not, i am fully english no hint of scottish, welsh or irish in me. It annoys me alot because when i show them the true english flag they say no thats not the english flag, and then showing me the british flag they say that is.

i think its just something that is unavoidable, both in sports and in your normal day-to-day life. I mean how many people do you know say 'oh i love the british accent', i mean theres no sucj thing, there isnt even set english, scottish, welsh or irish accents as they all change depending on the region your from.

David Vance said...

England is not allowed to exist as a nationality in the minds of the leftist elite in Government. That's why the preposterous "Celtic fringe" is now central! And I speak as someone from Northern Ireland. I feel great sympathy for the majority of my fellow Brits that dare not speak their name.

"Alice" said...

Obviously. And notice how it's frowned on if one dares flys the English flag; i.e. cars, homes, etc. It might be taken as too offensive for some. Screw that! Nuthin' wrong with being proud of one's country.

David Vance said...

Alice,

The probelm is that the ruling Labour elite are anti-English. With so many of them part of the Scottish Raj, and the remainder vehement EUrophiles, England is seen as a threat to their great prject of destroying the UK. I think that English people SHOULD be proud of their country and that other Brits like myself, owe them a huge debt for the freedoms we enjoy thanks to the brave English. They fund the rest of the UK, they take all the crap, and yet they remain benign but perhaps too sedated to the selling out of their own land?

Greg said...

Meanwhile in the Irish Republic we tend to notice a British tendency to claim Irish people as British whenever they do well. I wonder why?

Englishness was something deliberately played down by the British establishment from the start of the eighteenth century on - it was what was needed to convince the Scots they hadn't just signed up to become the junior partner in a 'Greater England'. It's a classic imperial gambit, really, reducing nationality to a toy for small countries - the Austrians did the same thing, and since the dissolution of their empire have wondered what exactly it means to be Austrian.

For what it's worth, I'd like to see the Cross of Saint George far more often. It's a beautiful, elegant flag, far more evocative than the gaudy banner more commonly flown here, referring back to an age when the English were preeminent in the European family, rather than simply heading an Empire that trampled half the world.

As for the 'Celtic fringe'? Yes, the idea's nonsense. The English are as Celtic as the Welsh, Cornish, Irish, or Scots.

Scottish Nationalist said...

David Vance "Fund the rest of the U.K" What nonsense! As they have taken and are taking the revenues from Scotland's, Orkney's and Shetland's oil. David Vance "take all the crap". Anthrax released on Gruinard island. Depleted uranium tank shells, fired in Dumfries and Galloway. Nuclear submarines based at Holy Loch. Plans to bury reactors from nuclear submarines in Scotland. Nuclear power station to be built in Scotland, just to supply England with electricity. Isle of Lewis to be covered in windfarms to supply England with electricity. "project of destroying the U.K." Labour are unionists. Simon "Scotland would probably empty overnight". Odd then that the Irish Republic, has one of the strongest economies in Europe. They don't seem desperate to re-join the U.K.! Scotland has a larger population, land area and more natural resources than the Irish Republic. Many countries in Europe have smaller populations or land areas than Scotland. Only unionist propaganda insists that Scotland could not be a successful country. I would hate to live in England. You English can keep your overcrowded country. To get independence for Scotland, I have always voted for the Scottish Nationalist party. As I am sick of being part of Greater England, and the Anglo-centric rubbish Scots are fed. Anglo commonly meaning Britain. When non-English are not "Anglo". e.g. Anglo-American. Scots subjected to 300 years of brainwashing and propaganda. Scots own history replaced by English history. The U.K. throughout the world, commonly referred to as "England". Robert Burns about the 1707 union of Parliaments. "Bought and sold for English gold. What parcel of rogues in a nation."

Scottish Nationalist said...

Robert Burn's

Robert Bruce March to Bannockburn

Scots, wha have wi' Wallace bled,
Scots, whom Bruce has often led,
Welcome to your gory bed,
Or to Victorie'.

Now's the day and now's the hour;
See the front of battle lour,
See approach proud Edward's power-
Chains and Slaverie!

Who will be a traitor knave?
Who can fill a cowards grave?
Who so base as be a slave?
Let him turn and flee!

Who, for Scotland's King and Law,
Freedom's sword will strongly draw,
Free-man stand or free-man fall,
Let him on with me!

By oppression's woes and pains!
Beside your sons in servile chans!
We will drain our dearest veins,
But they shall be free.

Lay the proud usurpers low!
Tyrants fall in every foe,
Liberty in every blow!
Let us do or die!

Scottish Nationalist said...

The Declaration of Arbroath 1320

To Pope XXII

"our nation did indeed live in freedom and peace up to the time when that mighty prince the King of the English, Edward, when our kingdom had no head and our people harboured no malice or treachery and were then unused to wars or invasions, came in the guise of a friend and ally to harass them as an enemy. The deeds of cruelty, massacre, violence, pillage, arson and other outrages without number which he committed against our people, sparing neither age nor sex, no one could describe nor fully imagine unless he had seen them with his own eyes.
Robert Bruce. Yet if he should agree to make us or our kingdom subject to the King of England or the English, we should at once drive him out as our enemy and make some other man able to defend us our king; for as long as but hundred of us remain alive, never will we on any conditions be brought under English rule. It is not for glory, nor riches, nor honours that we are fighting, but for freedom - for that alone, no honest man gives up with life itself.

Scottish Nationalist said...

Robert Burns
Farewell to our Scottish fame
Farewell to ancient glory
Farewell even to the Scottish name
So famed in martial history!
Now Sark runs over the Solway sands
And Tweed runs to the ocean
To mark where England's province stands.

What force or guile could not subdue
Through many warlike ages
Is wrought now by a coward few
Fot hireling traitor wages
The English steel we could disdain
Secure in valours station

Oh, would I had seen the day
That treason could sell us
With Bruce and loyal Wallace
With pith and power to my last hour
I'll make this declaration
We're bought and sold for English gold
Such parcel of rogues in a nation

Anonymous said...

What a great site Oldsmobile delta 88 1996 http://www.indianapolisjobopenings.info/strippoker-phoebe-mobile.html Find results for ebay.co.uk other pdas Short interacial adult stories Texac hold em unfinshed wall cabinets free online poker Poker odds on hold em hands Digital photo printing michigan Ballroom black casino jack Transmission valtrex Seo strategy western sahara Dangers of levitra best live nude webcams Buy online pharmacy soma buy tramadol now Cataplasme pour eczema Degrees school counseling 122c utah where can i order diet pills Valtrex 500mg. Lime green coffee maker

Anonymous said...

This is very interesting site... http://www.projector-parts-7.info/projector-tv-canada.html Tadalafil 180 pill online class attraction suite ritalin zyban Vardenafil dosage Upgrade coupon dollar rent a car nissan body kits Arizona accutane federal law subaru off road accessory http://www.hp-ink-cartridges-8.info Vehicle+insurance+rates+between+cars Forex+platform+trading lcd projectors and televisions Adipex addictionsymptoms ultracet purchase painkiller bextra doctor mohammed mondomi Projector rentals projectors reviewed